# Difference between revisions of "Segment 40. Markov Chain Monte Carlo, Example 1"

Bill Press (talk | contribs) |
Bill Press (talk | contribs) m (URL fix) |
||

Line 15: | Line 15: | ||

===Problems=== | ===Problems=== | ||

====To Calculate==== | ====To Calculate==== | ||

− | 1. The file [http:// | + | 1. The file [http://wpressutexas.net/coursefiles/Twoexondata.txt Twoexondata.txt] has 3000 pairs of (first, second) exon lengths. Choose 600 of the first exon lengths at random. Then, in your favorite programming language, repeat the calculation shown in the segment to model the chosen first exon lengths as a mixture of two Student distributions. That is (see slide 2): "6 parameters: two centers, two widths, ratio of peak heights, and Student t index." After running your Markov chain, plot the posterior distribution of the ratio of areas of the two Student components, as in slide 6. |

2. Make a histogram of the 2nd exon lengths. Do they seem to require two separate components? If so, repeat the calculations of problem 1. If not, use MCMC to explore the posterior of a model with a single Student component. Plot the posterior distribution of the Student parameter <math>\nu</math>. | 2. Make a histogram of the 2nd exon lengths. Do they seem to require two separate components? If so, repeat the calculations of problem 1. If not, use MCMC to explore the posterior of a model with a single Student component. Plot the posterior distribution of the Student parameter <math>\nu</math>. |

## Latest revision as of 15:00, 22 April 2016

#### Watch this segment

(Don't worry, what you see statically below is not the beginning of the segment. Press the play button to start at the beginning.)

{{#widget:Iframe |url=http://www.youtube.com/v/nSKZ02ZWzsY&hd=1 |width=800 |height=625 |border=0 }}

The direct YouTube link is http://youtu.be/nSKZ02ZWzsY

Links to the slides: PDF file or PowerPoint file

### Problems

#### To Calculate

1. The file Twoexondata.txt has 3000 pairs of (first, second) exon lengths. Choose 600 of the first exon lengths at random. Then, in your favorite programming language, repeat the calculation shown in the segment to model the chosen first exon lengths as a mixture of two Student distributions. That is (see slide 2): "6 parameters: two centers, two widths, ratio of peak heights, and Student t index." After running your Markov chain, plot the posterior distribution of the ratio of areas of the two Student components, as in slide 6.

2. Make a histogram of the 2nd exon lengths. Do they seem to require two separate components? If so, repeat the calculations of problem 1. If not, use MCMC to explore the posterior of a model with a single Student component. Plot the posterior distribution of the Student parameter .

#### To Think About

1. As a Bayesian, how would you decide whether, in problem 2 above, you need one vs. two components? What about 7 components? What about 200? Can you think of a way to enforce model simplicity?

2. After you have given a good "textbook" answer to the preceding problem, think harder about whether this can really work for large data sets. The problem is that even tiny differences in log-likelihood *per data point* become huge log-odds differences when the number of data points is large. So, given the opportunity, models are almost always driven to high complexity. What do you think that practical Bayesians actually do about this?